Hallelujah! Federal Court Judge Vaughn Walker determined that Proposition 8 “fails to advance any rational basis in singling out gay men and lesbians for denial of a marriage license.” This ruling is very similar to the Supreme Court judgement regarding a Colorado law that stated that gays “could make no claim of discrimination.” In that case the Supreme Court found that no state may “deem a class of persons a stranger to its laws.” These are two rulings that really illuminate the responsibility of law to conform to the Constitution.
What I don’t understand is why any citizen would support any law that denies or limits the rights of a subset of citizens. Clearly, that is a slippery slope that once taken can lead to the potential erosion of other rights.
This is not a religious issue. Being able to obtain a marriage license is the first step in a process that enables two people to merge their lives in all ways that matter. Medical decisions. Insurance coverage. Adoption. Property purchases. Public statement of commitment.
Why does anyone care if same sex couples marry? It doesn’t change the legal rights or strength of heterosexual marriage. In fact it could be said that it strengthens all marriage by establishing it as the ultimate measure of a couple’s commitment. Have we forgotten what it feels like to fall in love and realize that we want to spend the rest of our lives with another? And then to realize that through marriage those lives will be entwined in every way? How exciting to know that we would announce to the world that we had found our life partner. Why is it so important to steal that experience from those whose sexual orientation is different from ours? As I said, I just don’t get it!
My ability to choose to marry is the same today as it was yesterday. For me, nothing has changed. But for all of the gays in California much has changed. Think about that. Should the electorate or the government really have the power to control another’s life in that way? What if someone could say tomorrow that your marriage was void because you fell in love and married an Italian? Ridiculous?! Of course. The government shouldn’t be able to tell you who you can fall in love with and marry. Frankly, the government shouldn’t be involved in the love lives of consenting adults at all.
If you don’t think that gays should be able to marry, then don’t go to their weddings. If you think that gay marriage shouldn’t be recognized by religion, then don’t go to a church that does. But if you don’t think that gays should have the exact same rights as you, then you should find a country that isn’t governed by a constitution that was written to protect the rights of the few from the “tyranny of the majority”…
Some People’s Kids: Misguided. Just plain wrong.
